Advocates are more important than influencers

For some time I have been arguing that what brands need is advocates not influencers.  Somehow this meme has recently gathered steam in the marketing discussion (see great post here from Jeremy Epstein – influencers vs. fans)

I don’t think fans is quite the right word for what brands or movements need, what they need is advocates.  Advocates are different than fans because they will do something.  They will recommend you to a friend, they will tell someone else to buy your car.  They are taking positive action.   Moreover, they don’t do this because they are “influential” or because they are being paid by the post or enticed to write nice things b/c they are getting free stuff.  They are telling their friends (online and off) to do something, because they believe.

I have studied Brand Advocacy in some detail and I am confident in saying that increasing levels of advocacy (online and off) are correlated to increasing sales or share.  We have studied this in automotive, food, cellular, spirits and other markets with some variability (how much of the change in share or sales are explained by the change in advocacy; time lag) but always with a strong positive correlation.

When we work with brands, key questions are how many advocates do you have (compared to your competition) is the number increasing or decreasing and why?  Also, we examine what your advocates love about you most, and figure out how to leverage these things to grow advocacy.

Contrast this approach with Influencer marketing.  With adovocacy research and marketing we are trying to discover why your authentic brand fans love y0u most and how to make more advocates.  With influencer marketing you are trying to find those few people who will influence lots of other to do something.   Now like most things this works great if you get the right influencer, on the right topic.  Clearly Oprah Winfrey recommending a book to her audience is a guarantee of a NYT best seller.  Every other influencer works less well than that.

The other day I had a tweet with Guy Kawasaki about this very subject.  Guy has somehow Corvettewrangled a Corvette from GM to drive and tweet about as an “influencer”.  I respect Guy for lots of things, but is opinion is irrelevant to me as a car guy.   (Though Guy did confirm that it is fun for him!)  This is but one of many, many influencer strategies being deployed by big companies, and some of them will work.  But to me it feels more like Viral Marketing than anything else.  Rather than engaging your REAL brand users on the level of their personal brand experience, you are looking for a few influencers who will tell the rest of us sheep what to do.

What if instead of giving Guy (and I’m assuming a bunch of other “influencers”) a Corvette GM spent the resources engaging with the people over at the non-GM owned Corvette Forums which has 30 million posts from some 223,000 members?  Those are the Corvette advocates, and the care and feeding of the Corvette advocates (even if they aren’t famous) should be the #1 job of the Corvette PR and Marketing teams.

<RANT OFF>

TO’B

About these ads

4 Responses to Advocates are more important than influencers

  1. Jeremy says:

    I like what you’ve done with this, though I’m not a big fan of the term “viral Marketing” since I think it’s the effect, not the cause.

    Nonetheless, your assessment vis a vis Guy on the Corvette is right on

  2. tomob says:

    Hi Jeremy:

    I think we’re in agreement on “Viral Marketing”. It is no way to do marketing. One think that occurred to me in reading your post is that Influencer Marketing is very similar to Viral Marketing – you want something simple and cheap to do your work for you.

    TO’B

  3. Kate Brodock says:

    Great post Jeremy –

    It begs the question of whether or not your influencers also need to be advocates? In influencer marketing, it’s best practice to let the influencers give their honest opinions on products or services, therefore, it’s ideal that you find those influencers that also believe in your product. How does this fit into the mix?

    I would guess that the majority of influencers (that are also advocates) probably have less of a connection to your product/service than most advocates, as they get bombarded every day (unless you find their true sweet spot and the really become die-hards). So certainly the strength of their advocacy may not be as strong as the lesser-known true advocates.

    Cheers,
    Kate

  4. [...] them paid. It makes me (and everyone else) think less of them. I don’t think much of “influencer marketing” [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 7,750 other followers

%d bloggers like this: